GAME OF THRONES 1×05

"The Wolf and the Lion"

Spoiler Level: This review contains spoilers for the episodes that have aired to date, but no spoilers from the books.

Of all the shows on television that could feature a guy getting a knife through the eyeball, a bludgeoning dwarf, a breast-feeding 7-year-old, a spontaneous equine decapitation, and a discussion of the economics of cadaver fucking—all in the same episode—Game of Thrones has definitely become my favorite. The title of this episode refers to the two central houses—Stark and Lannister, respectively—that have been moving towards open hostility since Game of Thrones began. "The Wolf and the Lion will soon be at each other's throats," says Varys, the Spider (Conleth Hill), and by the end of this episode—the bloodiest of the season so far—he's right. "The Wolf and the Lion" isn't quite as thematically tight as last week's episode, but it makes up for it with sheer story acceleration, finally setting a match to much of the narrative kindling that's been piling up around Game of Thrones.

Or—to throw another metaphor into the mix—shit, meet fan.

But the title also emphasizes the theme of dichotomies that is central to this episode. There are some interesting parallels at work in "The Wolf and the Lion," some comparing-and-contrasting that helps bring certain characters into stark relief, and which serves to make clearer the issues at stake in Game of Thrones. An early scene picks up the dichotic theme from the episode's title, as the two Clegane brothers, the Mountain (Conan Stevens) and the Hound (Rory McCann), pair off against one another during the tournament. The brothers have certainly appeared equally terrifying and monstrous before now, but here a sharp contrast is drawn between them. Gregor, the Mountain, is all uncontrolled wrath and homicidal impulse, beheading his own horse in frustration and attempting to do the same to the Knight of Flowers (Finn Jones). While everyone else stands and watches—either in shock or in titillation—it is Sandor, the Hound, who leaps into the fray to stop his brother.  The Hound—who bears the terrible scars of his brother's rage—is every bit as formidable, but here we see he is less emotional, more reasoned, more conscious of duty. (Watch how the Hound drops to his knees in obedience the second the King commands them to stop fighting, even though his brother is still swinging his sword in rage.)

Ned (Sean Bean) and Robert (Mark Addy) in GOT 1x05

This relationship directly parallels that between Robert (Mark Addy) and Ned (Sean Bean), who are as close to being brothers as two men can be. Robert is all emotion and id, desperately wanting to "hit somebody," given to whoring and spending and abusing his servants. Ned—who also bears the scars of Robert's wars—is his friend's conscience, brought in as Hand of the King to temper Robert's wilder and more impulsive side. Sometimes it works—as when Ned dissuades the King from taking part in the joust—but he cannot persuade the King that murdering the pregnant Dany is not a justifiable act in the name of  homeland security. "I thought you were a better man," he tells the King, and— just a few episodes after accepting the job of King's Hand—he turns in his badge.

Meanwhile, Catelyn and her entourage are escorting their prisoner, Tyrion (Peter Dinklage) to The Eyrie, the impregnable tower home of Catelyn's sister (and Jon Arynn's widow), Lysa (Kate Dickie). But Lady Stark hasn't seen her sister in five years, and—as Tyrion reports— "She's changed."

Robin (Leno Facioli) and Lysa (Kate Dickie) in GOT 1x05

Really? You mean she wasn't batshit crazy before? Lysa gets a memorable and disturbing introduction, imperiously granting audience to her "guests" from atop a ridiculously high throne while casually breastfeeding her son Robin (Leno Facioli), who looks to be about 7 years old. Lysa is a warped, funhouse-mirror reflection of Catelyn, a slightly twisted re-interpretation of Catelyn's strength, and a perversion of the Tully House motto: "Family, Duty, Honor." Catelyn refused to leave her injured son's bedside, but Lysa refuses to let her son leave her breast; Lady Stark arrested the Imp, but Lady Arynn has him thrown in a terrifying cell with an open-air view of the sheer walls of The Eyrie, and seems to be entertaining her wet-chinned son's desire "to see the bad man fly."

(Okay, I'm just going to say this once: all this in-breeding is not good for the gene pool. You all are producing some fucked-up children. I mean, seriously.)

Varys (Conleth Hill) and Littlefinger (Aidan Gillen) in GOT 1x05

There are other meetings between shadow-selves throughout "The Wolf and the Lion." It's a very fine line, for example, that separates Baelish (Aiden Gillen) and Varys—they are both master manipulators and opportunists, in addition to being sexually predatory slimebags—but Varys seems to be playing every side in an effort to bring about a war, while Baelish—so far—seems to be weaseling on the side of good. The two square off for an exchange of venom in the throne room, before the same windows where Ned and Robert will have their confrontation, and there is a sense that Baelish and Varys may be the real rulers of this realm, the quiet, more effective shadows of Ned and Robert. They are the chess players, and Robert and Ned may just be pieces on the board. (This echoes Robert's comment to his wife that the realm has become "backstabbing and scheming and arse-licking and money-grubbing." The warriors may be out of date—relics of a simpler time—and the politicians may inherit the world.)

Robert and Cersei (Lena Headey) have what may be the first real conversation they've had with one another in years. Their talk begins with Ned Stark's dismissal and the politics of the Seven Kingdoms, and then pivots—on Cersei's observation that their marriage is what holds the Kingdoms together, which gives them both a good laugh—to a discussion of the late Lyanna Stark. She is Cersei's dark reflection, the ghostly counterpart with whom Cersei can never compete. "I don't even remember what she looked like," Robert admits—but he also admits that Lyanna's memory meant there was never a chance he could care about his Queen. It's a fabulously played scene, which humanizes both of them, but I'm less enthusiastic about Cersei's motives being reduced to the cliché of a woman scorned. I hope—and suspect—that it's more complicated than that.

(In fact, I suspect the Lannisters' father—often mentioned, but so far unseen—will shed a lot of light on how all three Lannisters turned out. I don't know when he'll turn up onscreen, but I have to imagine he's a force to be reckoned with.)

As, it turns out, is his son. By the end of the episode the news of Tyrion's arrest has reached King's Landing, and it has brought the simmering hostility between the Starks and the Lannisters to a boil. Jaime (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau) has previously seemed like a bit of a preening joke, but here he turns out to be a fairly nasty (and surprisingly competent) piece of work; his troops slaughter Ned's men, and shove a spear through Ned's leg, and Jaime himself pokes a dagger through the left eye of Jory (Jamie Sives), the one man Ned completely trusted in King's Landing.

Jaime (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau) in GOT 1x05

Jaime makes it clear that there will be more blood shed unless the Starks return his brother; unfortunately, that brother has just been delivered to the most impregnable fortress in the realm, into the hands of a woman who hates the Lannisters more than anyone. Yeah. This should all go well.

Random Observations and Speculations

  • I didn't get around to mentioning the relationship we discover this episode between the Knight of Flowers and the King's brother Renly, in part because I'm not sure how I feel about it yet. It's a discussion for another time, but I'm starting to wonder if Game of Thrones isn't the most conservative show on television right now: I'm getting a sense that, at its heart, there is a romanticism about traditional roles, and men being men, and a longing for simpler times. It seems the more feminine a man is in Game of Thrones—or even the more intellectual, which may amount to the same thing in this context—the slimier and more contemptible they are. Thoughts?
  • It would probably be foolish to spend too much time thinking about the animal sigils of each house—I suspect the metaphors would break down pretty quickly—but I find it interesting that the Baratheons, who currently hold the crown, are Stags: they are proud and bold, but they are fundamentally prey, and they are surrounded on all sides by predators (Lions, Wolves, Dragons). The show is called Game of Thrones, and at this point in the game, they hold the prize; it is only a matter of time before someone takes it away from them.
  • Though in a way, someone already has taken it, haven't they? I don't know yet how Ned Stark (Sean Bean)—following in the detective work of the late Jon Arynn—will finally piece together the truth, but it seems fairly obvious what that truth is. I am unspoiled on where this is all going, but I'd bet 100 gold dragons that all these bastard children of the King whom Ned is discovering have some trait in common—green eyes?—that none of the official heirs exhibit. The knowledge that Robert has bastards does not threaten the throne, but the fact that those are the only living children he really has must be the secret that got Jon Arynn killed. How long before the King figures out that his blonde haired, blue-eyed, deeply twisted princes and princesses are all the incestuous children of Cersei and Jaime? (Perhaps a better sigil for the Lannister House would be a Cuckoo.)
  • No Targaryans this week, no Dothrakis, no Jon Snow at The Wall, and still this episode had far too many strands to compile a particularly coherent summary. If I were getting paid for reviewing this show, I'd want more money.

 

The Unaffiliated Critic

Michael G. McDunnah is a freelance writer, a recovering lit major, a pop-culture junkie, and an unaffiliated critic. He lives in Chicago.

You May Also Like

Facebook Comments

WordPress Comments

4 thoughts on “GAME OF THRONES 1×05

  1. Great review, as always! I'm especially interested to see if your opinion that GOT might be the most conservative show on TV changes or not. I think it's a valid interpretation, considering what we've seen on screen.

    So far there's definitely a love for "traditional" family values (the Starks), a celebration of uncomplicated honorable men (Ned), and a suspicion of urbanity and barbarism both. Although I'd argue that all of this is an indirect result of translating the book's limited POVs into objective cinematic terms — in other words, everything we see is strongly inflected by Ned's and Dany's, and etc.'s POVs.

    So far I love the adaptation, but the Renly/Loras scene was the first one that I thought was possibly misjudged. It was certainly the first one I noticed as having been explicitly invented for the show; other scenes have differed from the book, but as far as I remember, they still bear a close resemblance to the source. But IIRC, the reader doesn't learn about Renly and Loras' relationship until maybe the second book — in AGOT, most of what we know about the Knight of Flowers is filtered through Sansa's naive perceptions. By moving up that revelation in the TV show, the producers are obviously trying to position those two as potential Westeros power players in viewers' minds, but by doing that they bring in a strong note of potential villainy and "unnatural" sexuality. Too early for this, I think — right now they just seem like decadent schemers, without sufficient political or personal motivation.

  2. Pat, the POV question is an interesting one; I've read elsewhere that the other scene wholly invented this week is the conversation between Robert and Cersei—true? One article I read mentioned that it had to be, since neither of them is a POV character in the books—which I also assume is true of Loras and Renly? (And come to think of it, are either Baelish or Varys POV characters?)

    Anyway, I'm reviewing the show, so I probably shouldn't drive myself crazy trying to figure out where it strays from the books, but I'm curious whether you think the Robert/Cersei scene was misjudged as well: as I said in the review, I thought it was a good scene, but it seemed to take Cersei's character in a totally different direction from anything we've seen before—less Lady Macbeth and more Betty Draper.

  3. You're right — I hadn't thought of it until now, but the Robert/Cersei scene and the Varys/Littlefinger scene were also both invented for the show. As for what I thought of them…

    I'm finding it tricky to comment on some of the TV stuff, given that it's so faithful to the books, so I know where it's all leading. In a way, talking about a much worse show, like The Walking Dead, which deviates so thoroughly from the source material, would be easier.

    That being said, I found the Varys/Littlefinger scene enjoyable but a little too arch. I thought the Robert/Cersei scene was terrific, and well in keeping with a certain legitimate interpretation of the characters.

    Both of these scenes, and the Loras/Renly one, probably exist mostly to give the actors something to do. In the books, Martin has the luxury of playing a very long game, and keeping some players deep in the background until the right moment. In a TV adaptation it's probably important to use Aiden Gillen or Lena Headey often enough that the audience doesn't forget about them. In the books, they can remain ciphers for as long as Martin needs, but on screen they become characterized almost by default.

  4. The heraldry imagery comes out early on in Ep1 when they find the stag and the wolf in the woods having killed each other, leaving the wolf's offspring orphans.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

9 Shares
Share8
Tweet
+1
Share
Pin1
Email